- One new review found that ultraprocessed foods (UPFs) could be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The study authors observed that UPFs are formulated to maximize reward and speed up the absorption of reinforcing ingredients.
- The habit-forming property of such products suggests they fuel compulsive consumption and hinder appetite regulation.
- The review authors propose that ultraprocessed foods could be governed by policies similar to those for tobacco products.
At present, there is no single agreed-upon definition of UPFs. Certain experts describe them as foods that include components you are unlikely to have in a personal cupboard, like emulsifiers and additives.
Numerous experts employ the NOVA system to classify ultraprocessed foods. This refers to foods that contain “combinations of components, mostly of exclusive industrial use, often produced by a series of industrial techniques and methods.”
A fresh paper released by The Millbank Quarterly suggested that UPFs could be as addictive as cigarettes.
“It is my view with this research, as ultra-processed foods are intentionally formulated to be extremely attractive to most individuals,” commented a weight loss specialist not affiliated with the research.
A study from last year suggests that over 73% of the food supply in the America are highly processed.
“Cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods are not just whole foods but carefully designed delivery systems engineered deliberately to increase biological and psychological reinforcement and compulsive consumption,” noted the new study’s scientists.
Are UPFs Habit-Forming?
The review combined data from addiction, public health history, and dietary science in order to identify sensory and structural characteristics that increase the rewarding nature of both tobacco and UPFs.
“Not everyone is ‘hooked’ to these foods, but for a meaningful minority, they trigger typical addiction-like patterns: strong cravings, inability to stop, and continued use even with negative health effects,” commented a heart health nutrition expert.
“These products are deliberately engineered with refined carbs, added fats, sodium, and flavor enhancers to optimize pleasure and repeat consumption, and the food sector employs aggressive marketing tactics, particularly targeting young people,” she stated.
The researchers focused on five key areas:
- delivery speed
- hedonic engineering, or designing foods to be irresistibly good
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “wellness branding”
The study concluded that, similar to cigarettes, UPFs are carefully calibrated to deliver the optimal amount of sugar.
“Refined carbohydrates trigger dopamine production through the vagus nerve, while lipids achieve this via intestinal lipid sensing,” the researchers explained.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with high levels of refined carbohydrates and added fats are some of the most potently rewarding foods in the modern diet. Notably this refined carbohydrate-fat mix is almost nonexistent in whole foods.”
The way these foods quickly deliver “pleasure-inducing” substances to the brain makes them likely habit-forming, similarly to cigarettes.
The review stated that while cigarettes are engineered to deliver nicotine rapidly, UPFs are formulated to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they usually have little to no fiber. This allows for the body to process fat and sugar more quickly.
Authors also point out that UPFs provide deliberate flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This collectively works to deliver more dopamine and prompts individuals to eat more.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Tobacco, UPFs
Based on the analysis, both the tobacco and food sectors have historically employed a strategy known as “health washing.”
This refers to when goods are marketed and reformulated to create an perception of reduced harm while preserving the essential of their qualities.
Health washing in the tobacco industry gained traction in the 1950s with the advent of filter tips on cigarettes.
They were marketed as protective innovations that would trap tar and particles prior to they entered the lungs. Actually, these tips provide little significant benefit.
However, people typically adjusted by inhaling deeper or smoking more frequently, which negated any decrease in toxin exposure.
Food manufacturers has taken a similar approach. It employs labels such as “low fat” or “no sugar added” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
However, these foods often retain the very highly reinforcing formulations. The problem is that these reformulations offer a surface-level appearance of wellness while the product’s habit-forming nature and health risks remain intact.
Should UPFs Be Regulated?
The authors noted at the conclusion of their paper that nourishment and smoking products are not the same thing.
Nevertheless, they warned that certain ultraprocessed foods function like highly optimized consumables rather than actual food. They recommended that health regulations ought to acknowledge this reality.
“Tobacco provides a warning, and tobacco control offers a source of potential,” the researchers wrote.
Due to regulations, smoking levels in the US have fallen and have “reshaped cultural views of tobacco and diminished trust in the industry.”
“It is my opinion increased awareness about the negative impact of UPFs is essential to reduce general consumption and improve public health. The approaches used to reduce tobacco use have been effective and could be a useful model for UPFs as well,” said one expert.
“It is not my view UPFs should be regulated exactly like tobacco, but they do warrant more robust, tobacco-inspired policies: marketing restrictions, clear packaging warnings, stricter standards on health claims, and restrictions in schools or medical facilities,” added another dietitian.
The researchers reminded people that minimally processed and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.